17 Comments
User's avatar
barbara Durieux Coanda's avatar

Excellent as always, dear Etgar!

Delighted to discover that Liberation invites amazing (at least one!) authors to collaborate on a yearly edition. Love the idea. Almost proud to be French.

Expand full comment
Yael Gelardin's avatar

Depressing but oh so accurate! Thank you for your sharp views on what we are going through!

Expand full comment
Adam kubi's avatar

Oh no.

After the introductory paragraph, I was honestly expecting a quirky little story about someone who can change the weather for an hour a day. At first he thinks it’s kind of lame, then ends up saving someone's life with a surprise thunderstorm or well-timed breeze and finally feels much better about it. Maybe even lives happily ever after.

Expand full comment
Under The Fainting Couch's avatar

As always, a unique take on the world (of insanity). ❤️

Expand full comment
Leah Greenspan's avatar

This is the art of a powerful short story. Toda Etgar 🙏

Expand full comment
Drew's avatar

I empathize with the imperative to not "leave home without ... suitable protest gear," but what I keep asking my sane friends is — "What's the plan of action?" How about a column to solicit readers' best ideas for signs (or protest gear), or practical acts of resistance?

Expand full comment
Under The Fainting Couch's avatar

It would be great if you could provide that.

Expand full comment
Etgar Keret's avatar

I’ll try and write one. It will be an obscure pragmatic plan, I warn in advance.

Expand full comment
Under The Fainting Couch's avatar

That was meant for Drew. 😉

Expand full comment
sara sims's avatar

Cloudy with a downpour of injustice.

Expand full comment
Barbara Levinson's avatar

I’m starting to worry if my lineage in America goes back far enough for me to not get picked off the street and sent to a foreign prison. All my grandparents came here in steerage to escape the Cossacks. Will I have to go back?!

Expand full comment
DK Brooklyn's avatar

Sadly there is no silver lining in this weather report. It is actually worse. These fascists are not just planning to deport foreigners. They will deport domestics as well - protestors, intellectuals, LBGTQ, are in danger and this is just the beginning… meanwhile most people are more focused on the financial pages (also in the back of the paper) and wish they could get the insider tips.

Expand full comment
Under The Fainting Couch's avatar

https://youtu.be/k0PhviW_vek?si=4mRb1qoZA3Gz2XA_

See the comment about “homegrowns”.

Expand full comment
Elibec's avatar

Fantastic Etgar! I love it! I especially love pieces where you cite your mother (even if it’s not your actual mother, but a fictional one). She sounds like she was a fab person.

Expand full comment
Carol Green Ungar's avatar

That's who you are worried about? Not Sisi, Erdogan or the Ayattollahs? Get real.

Expand full comment
Drew's avatar

Worry about them all. Do something to oppose those you can.

Expand full comment
Etgar Keret's avatar

Worry about what you need to worry about but while doing that, don’t forget to take an umbrella.

Expand full comment